A basic pie crust – Short crust pastry science

There are a lot of different styles and types of pie crusts, some are sweet, some savoury. Some crunchy, some soft and tender. Your heritage will probably determine what you call a standard or basic pie crust. That makes the title of this blog post a little dangerous, but consider this the FoodCrumbles basic for a crunchy stand alone pie crust. It can be made with or without any filling. Which is another good reason to call it a basic crust, there’s plenty opportunity for variation, what about stewed beef or chicken and leek? The crust itself is savoury, but you can fill it with a sweet filling of course.

If this type of crust is done well, you will get a layered crunchy texture. By adding and mixing the ingredients in the right order these layers are formed. This type of dough is called short crust pastry dough and can also be used to bake cookies. Once you understand why you have to take certain steps, it will certainly improve your crust quality. Also, it will help you look out for the right type of ingredients!

What is short crust pastry?

Short crust pastry dough is a special type of dough, made with mostly fat and flour. In this type of dough the fat is rubbed into the flour. Only once the fat has been ‘rubbed’ in will you add extra moisture (water or milk for instance). The trick of this type of pastry is that the fat will form little pockets of fat within the dough. Then, when the dough is baked, this fat will melt away. As a result, the crust will have a layered texture of various dough layers on top of one another, separated by empty pockets where formerly the fat sat.

This structures gives a very crunchy but also sturdy pie crust. The flakiness will make it easy to bite into and break. So whenever looking to make short crust pastry you’ll be trying to make these layers of fat in your flour.

Keeping everything cold

In all recipes for short crust pastry you will find that you have to work cold. Use cold fats, cold liquids, don’t let the dough heat up. So why is that?

When you’re making short crust pastry you’re trying to make these pockets of fat in the dough. Common fats to use for this are butter, shortening or lard. You wouldn’t use oils. Oils are liquid and won’t form these little chunks or pockets of fat. Instead, the oil will flow everywhere. It can still be used for make a nice dough. However, it won’t get that flaky texture that you’re after for a short crust pastry dough. This does mean that when using butter or lard, the butter or lard shouldn’t melt. If they melt, it will have the same effect as using an oil.

This is why you have to work cool. Butter starts melting at room temperature, it becomes noticeably softer, which is a sign that part of the fats have melted. The same goes up for shortening and lard. So, during the whole pastry making process you’re trying to keep them solid and you do this by keeping everything cool.

Type of fat in short crust pastry

The three most commonly used fats in short crust pastry are (clarified) butter, lard and shortening. They will all give a slightly different texture and structure to the final dough, it will also impact flavour. Shortening has little to no flavour, whereas butter has quite a lot of flavour. Flavour is very personal though and depends on the type of pie you’re planning to make. The impact on structure has some more scientific ground.

Lard has the highest melting point of the three fats. At room temperature it will be more solid than butter. The next highest melting point is that of shortening and butter melts at the lowest temperature. That means that butter tends to melt more easily when mixing it in the flour. Therefore, shortening and lard tend to be easier to work with.

In general these three fats can be substituted 1:1 in a recipe. You will also often find that people use combinations of two of the fats. Everyone has their own preference. In Europe shortening is not a very common ingredient, so most doughs tend to be made with either butter or solid margarine. In the recipe below you will find that butter is used, but feel free to change these fat ratios up as one of your experiments.

cranberry apple pie close up
Cranberry apple pie with crispy short crust pastry. The pastry is so strong it holds itself up even when the apples and cranberries have shrunk.

Role of liquid

Mixing only fat and flour won’t give a good crust. Instead, it will not properly cook and crumble apart very easily. Therefore, after the butter has been mixed in to the flour, some sort of liquid will be mixed in. This can be water or milk for instance. This water will actually bring the dough together and form it into a ball. Also, it will help the flour to cook, by absorbing part of the water in the dough.

In some cases eggs are added as well. This will enrich the dough further by adding some extra fats (of the egg yolk). Also, the egg proteins can help to form a sturdy structure. As long as you choose your fat:flour:liquid ratio properly though, they aren’t essential.

Gluten?

There is barely any gluten network formation in a short crust pastry. Once the (cold!) liquid is added it is mixed for as short as possible. Just enough for the dough to come together. Since gluten needs time and kneading to develop, this will not play an important role in short crust pastry.

Role of flour

If you live in Europe and want to try out American recipes or vice versa, you might have to watch out with short crust pastry. If you use European flour with an American recipe you might find that there is way too much fat in the recipe. Instead of creating a crumbly structure of fat and flour, you might have made a soft dough ball already, even before adding the liquid.

In the US a common ratio of flour:fat seems to be 3:2, whereas in Europe a good ratio tends to be 2:1. Keep this in mind when reading the recipes below! Also, use your eyes to determine whether the pastry is done. Once it’s become a good crumbly texture with larger and smaller chunks it’s good. If however, the dough still feels like plain flour or it has already come together in a ball, you’ve probably added too much or too little fat.

There are well known differences between these two types of flour, e.g. protein content, moisture content. However, these don’t necessarily seem to tell the whole story.

If your final crust doesn’t seem to want to cook or stays very very crumbly, there’s a chance you’ve added too much butter and it can’t hold itself together anymore.

Baking a short crust pastry

There are two ways to bake your short crust pastry:

  • Blind baking: you don’t yet put in the filling, instead, you weigh it down with something to help it keep its shape during baking. You then remove that filling and will only add the real filling in after.
  • Regular baking: bake the crust with the filling inside

When to blind bake your crust?

Blind baking is ideal if your filling might interact with the raw pie crust. Blind baking helps to cook the flour and will dry out the crust. That way it is less prone to soaking up moisture of a filling for instance.

In the case of our beef or chicken pies you would blind bake first since these have very moist fillings. The moisture might actually transfer into the crust, preventing it from baking properly.

Another reason to blind bake is of course if your filling doesn’t have to be cooked at all. Also, in some cases the filling should only be baked for a very short amount of time, resulting in a miss match of the baking times. Last but not least, if a filling does not come up very high in the pie, it is good the blind bake first. The blind baking will help secure the sides of the pie crust against the baking tin.eggless pie crust super flakyAn example of a blind baked crust, it will be filled with a super moist spinach filling.

Basic pie crust recipes

That leaves us with a few suggestions for making your ideal pie crust.

Short crust pastry pie crust
 
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
 
Author:
Recipe type: Pie crusts
Serves: 1 pie crust
Ingredients
Most basic pie crust (used for the apple pie on these photos)
  • Makes enough for both a bottom as well as decoration on top.
  • 320g flour
  • 150g butter
  • 80g cold water
The pie crust used for the beef stew pie
  • Makes enough for 2 bottoms (or bottom + top).
  • 300g flour
  • 140g butter
  • 1 egg (cool, directly from the fridge)
  • 50 ml water (as cold as possible, add two ice cubes and let it cool for a few minutes)
Eggless pie crust with fat variation
  • This makes enough to cover the bottom of a medium sized pie tray.
  • 130g flour
  • 35g butter (cold)
  • 25g shortening (cold)
  • 21g cold water
  • 21g milk (you may substitute this for water as well, but the extra protein and fat might just lift it up a little)
Instructions
  1. Cut the fat (butter/shortening) into the flour until you get a fine breadcrumb structure. Use either a special tool, or a stand mixer, see for more tips further down.
  2. You should end up with a crumbly structure, smaller and larger balls of fat in the dough. You should not be able to form it into a ball yet, instead it should crumble apart immediately.
  3. Add the cold liquids (egg, water, milk), colder is better, but not frozen.
  4. Quickly mix liquid through to shape a firm ball. It should have a slight tendency to crumble. If it's too dry add some extra water. If it's too wet add extra flour, but try to limit this, you want fat pockets everywhere. If it's really really wet, it's better to start over again.
  5. Cool dough back in the fridge for 15 minutes if it has warmed up quite a bit. Do not leave it in too long if you're only using butter as a fat, the dough will become too firm to roll.
  6. If making the large portion, split the dough in two balls. Roll the first one out flat and place in pie shape. Save the other half for the top.
Blind baking
  1. Cover the dough with parchment paper (or aluminium foil) and fill with baking beans (or dried lentils or beans, a lot cheaper and works perfectly).
  2. Bake the crust at 180C for approx. 15 minutes. The crust should now be able to keep its shape.
  3. Take out the beans and place back in the oven for another 10 minutes, it will now brown nicely.
  4. If the filling needs to be baked, you can now add it as well as the possible top of the pie and bake it for at least another 15 minutes at 180C (follow recipe).
No blind baking
  1. In some cases you can fill the filling immediately. Follow the recipe if it says to do so. Take at least 30 minutes at 180C to properly bake the crust.

Some pie crust making tips!

It’s important to properly incorporate the fat into the flour as you’ve learned here. So to finish of, two simple tips that will sav you a lot of tired hands. You can of course mix the flour and butter with your hands, but there are two great alternatives as well though (see recipe also):

  1. Use a stand mixer for mixing the fat + flour, this will give a very fine mixture, so it is worthwhile to shortly work it with your hands to create some larger lumps
  2. Use a dough cutter, this simple tool will make your life so much easier! You might not believe it will work at first, but it works like a charm.

dough cutter

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *